cooperation

Couverture – Compliance et droits de la défense

Articles in a JoRC book

📝Les conditions de réussite de l’enquête interne dans les rapports entre le Parquet national financier et l’entreprise mise en cause. L’enquête interne au soutien de la défense de l’entreprise

► Full reference : J.-F. Bohnert, « Les conditions de réussite de l’enquête interne dans les rapports entre le Parquet national financier et l’entreprise mise en cause – l’enquête interne au soutien de la défense de l’entreprise » (The Conditions for a Successful Internal Investigation in Relations between the National Financial Prosecutor’s Office and the Company Concerned – the Internal Investigation in Support of the Company’s Defence), in M.-A. Frison-Roche and M. Boissavy (eds.), Compliance et droits de la défense. Enquête interne – CJIP – CRPC, Journal of Regulation & Compliance (JoRC) and Dalloz, coll. “Régulations & Compliance“, 2024, pp. 77-82. - ► English Summary of this article (made by the Journal of Regulation & Compliance – JoRC) : In his contribution, the National Financial Prosecutor recalls that he has expressed his conception of internal investigations in guidelines and a guide, documents which “describe a practice and meet objectives of transparency and predictability for the public and economic players”. He considers that a company confronted with a suspected offence must decide whether to launch an internal investigation, in particular in order to reorganise itself. If this approach contributes to establishing the truth, it will be credited in any subsequent proceedings. The conditions and procedures of the investigation must be satisfactory, in particular as regards the gathering of information, the procedural guarantees offered to persons and the drafting of the investigation report. If the report reveals “conduct not in compliance with the procedures established internally”, the company may draw the judicial and/or disciplinary consequences. The author stresses that the analysis must be carried out independently of the drafting of the report so as not to bias the presentation of the facts. It is recalled that the guidelines invite the company to spontaneously inform the PNF of the facts revealed by the investigation, which allows the company to claim a “negotiated and softened criminal response” because of this “attitude of cooperation and good faith” and the “seriousness” of the investigations carried out, while the PNF conducts a criminal investigation. The PNF may moreover request disclosure of the execution reports, engagement letters, etc. of the internal investigation. On the other hand, a “defensive” internal investigation, for example opened after the opening of the criminal investigation, could be counterproductive. Conversely, cooperation may be established, the PNF being able to propose a document framing an internal investigation, a timetable, etc., which may result in continuous links between the PNF and the company throughout the internal investigation. The PNF considers that, if lawyers intervene in this context, they must be different from those who intervene in the parallel or subsequent criminal proceedings.

Articles

Interregulation: way of “cooperation protocol”​ between Regulatory Bodies.Example between French Financial Markets Authority and Anticorruption Agency

Full reference: Frison-Roche, M.-A., Interregulation: way of "cooperation protocol"​ between Regulatory Bodies. Example between French Financial Markets Authority and Anticorruption Agency, Newsletter MAFR – Law, Compliance, Regulation, 22nd of September 2020 Read by freely subscribing other news of the Newsletter MAFR – Law, Compliance, Regulation   Summary of the news:  Although Regulation Law was born from the notion "sector", constant interferences between sectors and frequent interactions between some sectors and more general questions common to different sectors, make interregulation necessary. Compliance Law being the extension of Regulation Law, this interregulation mechanism is also necessary in Compliance Law.  This interregulation can take many legal paths like letters exchanges between regulators, the creation of a network of regulators and supervisors at the world level or about some specific question or the adoption of a "cooperation protocol" as the AMF (French Financial Market Regulator) and the AFA (French Anticorruption Agency) did on 16th of September 2020 to reinforce their respective fight against corruption, against market abuses and for the protection of investors.  This cooperation protocol between the AFA and the AMF has the following subjects: A more efficient methodology concerning the research and the analysis of corruption and market abuses. A more efficient prevention of corruption and market abuses. A better capacity to give recommendations of new regulations to the Legislator. A more rigorous monitoring of international works on the topic.  A more coherent information for the public. Are regulators the new teachers? 

Articles

Compliance & Regulatory Soft Law, legal Certainty and Cooperation: example of the U.S. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network new Guidelines on AML/FT.

Full reference: Frison-Roche, M.-A., Compliance & Regulatory Soft Law, legal Certainty and Cooperation: example of the U.S. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network new Guidelines on AML/FT, Newsletter MAFR – Law, Compliance, Regulation, 2nd of September 2020 Read by freely subscribing other news of the Newsletter MAFR – Law, Compliance, Regulation   Summary of the news The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) is an organ, depending on the American Treasury, in charge of fighting against financial criminality and especially against money laundering and terrorism financing. For this, it has large control and sanction powers.  In August 2020, the FinCEN published a document untitled "Statement on Enforcement" which aimed to explicit its control and sanction methods. It reveals what firms risk in case of offense (from the simple warning letter to criminal pursuits passing through financial fines) and the different criteria on which FinCEN is based to use one sanction rather than another. Among these criteria, we find for examples the nature and the seriousness of committed violations or the firm's history but also the implementation of compliance program or the quality and the spread of the cooperation with FinCEN durning the investigation.  One of the objectives of the publication of such an information document is to obtain the cooperation of firms by creating a confidence relationship between the regulator and the regulated firm. However, it is very difficult to ask to the firms to cooperate and to furnish information if they can fear that this same information can be used later as proof against them by the FinCEN.  Another objective is to reinforce legal security and transparency. However, the FinCEN's declaration does not seem to commit it, because it is not presented as a chart but as a simple declaration. Indeed, the list of the possible sanctions and the criteria used by the FinCEN are far from being exhaustive and can be completed in concreto by the FinCEN without any justification.

Articles

Can Coordination between local Regulators replace a unique centralized Regulator? Example of the European organisation of the Open Internet Principle

Full reference: Frison-Roche, M.-A., Can Coordination between local Regulators replace a unique centralized Regulator? Example of the European organisation of the Open Internet Principle, Newsletter MAFR – Law, Compliance, Regulation, 18th of August 2020 Read, by freely subscribing, the other news of the Newsletter MAFR – Law, Compliance, Regulation To go further, read Marie-Anne Frison-Roche's article: The hypothesis of interregulation    Summary of the news The principle of "open internet" enshrined in the European regulation of 30th of April 2016 guaranteeing a non discriminatory access to Internet contents and services. However, there is no European regulator to implement such a principle. Is it possible to guarantee the effectivity of this principle without a central regulator in charge of this principle?  On 11st of June 2020, the BEREC (Body of European Regulators for Electronic Communications) adopted guidelines concerning the application of the open internet principle. The BEREC is not a European regulator but a network of national regulators aiming to coordinate their actions. This body is only a consultative body but its recommendations are taken into account by national authorities which have deep legal power, as Osborne-Clarke said about the technical implementation of the European principle of open internet at the national level.   It is thus non necessary to have a central regulator to ensure the effectivity of a principle since the moment when there is a local regulators network able to coordinate their actions through soft law.   

I-1.32: Innovation and Regulation serving the digital Revolution

ENGLISH In the most developed nations, as in emerging countries, the economy and society are currently being entirely transformed by an industrial revolution originating in information and communication technologies. Anti-competitive Behaviour Audacity – Autorité de Régulation des Communications Electroniques et des Postes (ARCEP – French Electronic Communications and Posts Regulator) – Communication – Competition – Confidence – Cooperation – Darwin – Digital revolution – Discrimination – European Commission – Ex ante / Ex post – Fiber optic – Future – impredictibility – Information – Infostructure – Infrastructure – Innovation – Internet – Lamarck – Napoleon – Network – Overregulation – Risk – Uncertainty – Underregulation * * In The Journal of Regulation, these keywords are done by the Editor and not by the Author. ITALIAN Articolo: Innovazione e regolazione al servizio della rivoluzione digitale Nelle nazioni le più sviluppate, nonché negli stati in via di sviluppo, l’economia e la società sono completamente trasformati da un rivoluzione industriale che trova le sue origini nelle teconologie d’informazione e di comunicazione. Autorité de Régulation des Communications Electroniques et des Postes (ARCEP – Autorità francese di regolazione dei servizi postali e di telecomunicazione) – Commissione Europea – Comportamento anticoncorrenziale – Comunicazione – Concorrenza – Cooperazione – Darwin – Deregolamentazione – Discriminazione – Ex ante / Ex post – Fibra ottica – Imprevisibilità – Incertezza – Inflazione normativa – Informazione – Infostruttura – Infrastruttura – Innovazione – Internet – Lamarck – Napoleone – Rete – Rischio – Rivoluzione digitale * * In The Journal of Regulation, le parole chiave sono responsabilità dell’Editore e non dall’Autore.   PORTUGUESE Artigo: Inovação e Renovação a serviço da Revolução digital. Nos países mais desenvolvidos, bem como nos em desenvolvimento, a economia e a sociedade vem sendo, atualmente, completamente transformados por uma revolução industrial baseada em tecnologias da informação e da comunicação. Comportamento anti-concurrencial – Autoridade de regulação das comunicações eletrônicas e dos correios (ARCEP – Regulador francês de Comunicações e dos Correios) – Comunicação – Concorrência – Confiança – Cooperação – Darwin – Revolução digital – Discriminação – Comissão Europeia – Ex ante / Ex post – Fibra ótica – Futuro – Imprevisibilidade – Informação – Info-estrutura – Infra-estrutura – Inovação – Internet – Lamarck – Napoleão – Rede – Sobre-regulação – Risco – Incerteza – Sub-regulação.*  * No Journal of Regulation, as palavras-chave são fornecidas pelo Diretor, e não pelo Autor. SPANISH Artículo: Innovación y regulación sirviendo la revolución digital En las naciones más desarrolladas, tal como en los países emergentes, la economía y la sociedad están actualmente siendo transformadas por una revolución industrial provenientes de las tecnologías informáticas y de telecomunicaciones.     Other translations forthcoming.