27 November 2019 ·

Anchor points of the risk mapping process in the legal system

LinkedIn X

 

This Working Paper served as the basis for an intervention in the conference organized in the conference cycle organized by the Journal of Regulation & Compliance (JoRC) on the theme: Compliance Tools, in collaboration with many university partners: this first conference is organized in collaboration with the Sciences po Economics Department and is held on November 28, 2019 at Sciences po and deals with the more specific theme of Risk mapping.

It also serves as the basis for the book edited by Marie-Anne Frison-Roche, Compliance Tools, which will be released in the Regulations & Compliance collection.

 

______

 

 Is the consideration by Law of the Risk Mapping mechanism so new?

At first glance yes, and one might even be surprised at this novelty, since this rational anticipation of risks should have been recognized for a long time. But this is perhaps due to the more general fact that Risk itself has only recently become an autonomous legal object in Economic Law, in particular because Risk does not have at all the same position in Competition Law and in Regulation Law (I) .. Its position is even opposed in the both, Risk becoming central in Regulation Law. Compliance Law being the extension of Regulatory Law, it is also built on the "concern" of Risk and the internalization of this consideration in enterprises therefore takes the form of mapping.

A closer look maybe not,even  before the specific  French laws, called "Sapin 2" and "Vigilance" and beyond them, case law decisions giving a general scope to maps drawn up by operators, or increasing the obligation that 'they have to do it (II). In this, general and precise technical Law offers points of support for Compliance Law, strengthening it in its tools.

 


  1. On the AFA website, this sanctioning power is not presented as an autonomous power. It is simply indicated in general that the Agency has "administrative supervisory power enabling it to verify the reality and the efficiency of the anti-corruption compliance mechanisms implemented". The internet user must then go to the section specific to the "Sanctions Commission" to find information specific to the sanctions.
  2. V. d'une façon général, Frison-Roche, M.-A., La Mondialisation vue du point de vue du Droit, 2017.
  3. Frison-Roche, M.-A., Leçon probatoire de la décision du 4 juillet 2019 de la Commission des sanctions de l'Agence Française Anticorruption: le président de l'Agence, organe de poursuite ne supporte que la charge d'allégation et l'entreprise doit prouver l'exécution de son obligation de compliance, présumée si elle se conforme aux recommandations de l'Agence, 2019.
  4. Sur le fait que l'Union européenne est construit sur le Droit, constitue un Etat de Droit, ce par rapport à quoi les principes de concurrence, c'est-à-dire les trois libertés de circulation des personnes, des marchandises et des capitaux, ainsi que la libre rencontre de l'offre et de la demande, ne constituent que des principes seconds, v. Lenaerts, K., ..., in Pour une Europe de la Compliance, 2019. 
  5. Frison-Roche, M.-A., Du Droit de la Régulation au Droit de la Compliance, 2017. 
  6. V. d'une façon générale Frison-Roche, M.-A., Le Droit et le Risque, 2004....
  7. See for instance the supports dedicated to Compliance Officers in their training day organized by AMF, 2015. 
  8. Dyens, S., La nécessité de dresser une cartographie des risques juridiques, 2012. In this article which presents the Law as a risk for the action of the State and the good end of public policies, it is a question of organizing well in Ex Ante the administrations.
  9. Supiot, A., Prendre la responsabilité au sérieux, 2015. 
  10. Frison-Roche, M.-A., Compliance : avant, maintenant, après, 2018. 
  11. Osten, Th., Droit de la concurrence et assurance : cartographie des risques au lendement de l'enquête sectorielle de la Commission européenne et de l'adoption du nouveau Réglement d'exemption catégorielle, 212. 
  12. On the questioning of classic criminal law by Compliance Law, see. generally André, Ch., Droit pénal spécial, 2019; in banking and financial matters, c. Frison-Roche, M.-A., La nature prométhéenne du Droit en construction en matière bancaire et financière, 2014.
  13. Conseil d'Etat, 16 mars 2017, Numéricable ; Finvest....
  14. Even if today "love of the Law" is articulated even with the postulates of Economic Law, correlated with the economic analysis of Law and based on the notion of interest. However, as Pascal exposes, love and interest are opposite things. For a sociological analysis, see. Frison-Roche, M.-A., ....
  15. Sur la résolution de cette difficulté logique par la définition du Droit de la Compliance, en le distinguant fortement de la "Conformité", v. la première partie de cette étude. 
  16. Financial Markets Authority, Risk Mapping, 2017
  17. OCDE, Bueb, J.-P., Risk mapping methodology. Developping practical tools for procurement, 2008,  : "OBJECTIVES OF RISKS MAPPING • Put in place efficient means to reduce risks of frauds and corruption; • Have more efficient investigations by concentrating the efforts on “sensitive” processes, methods or persons. "
  18. V. not. Frison-Roche, M.-A., Du Droit de la Régulation au Droit de la Compliance, 2017 ; Regulation, Supervision, Compliance (dir.) , 2017.
  19. V. for ex. Dyens, S., La nécessité de dreser une cartographie des risques juridiques, 2012 ;  Elaborer une cartographie des risques juridiques, 2017. 
  20. Sur la question générale du rapport entre Droit de la Concurrence et Droit de la Compliance, v. Frison-Roche, M.-A., Droit de la concurrence et Droit de la compliance, 2017 ; entrée "Droit de la compliance" in Dictionnaire du Droit de la concurrence, à paraître. 
  21. V. par exemple l'article 410-1 du Code de commerce : "